When it comes to manufacturing processes, businesses are faced with the often-but decision of choosing the right method for producing parts. Two commonly used methods are sheet metal stamping and CNC machining (Computer Numerical Control machining).
Both techniques come with their advantages and unique applications. In this blog, we will review sheet metal stamping vs. CNC machining, the benefits associated with either option and factors to consider when selecting the best method for the project.
What is Sheet Metal Stamping?
Metal stamping refers to the process of turning flat sheets of metal into various shapes – by stamping presses applying successive punch impacts, causing cuts, shapes, or adjustments into specific designs.
In metal stamping, the metals commonly used are aluminum, stainless steel, and copper.
Advantages of Sheet Metal Stamping
High Production Volume: Sheet metal stamping has amazing efficiency in producing huge quantities of parts. Once done with the tooling, thousands of parts can be processed very fast.
Cost-Effective: The cost per part gets less as many parts are made at high production speeds; unlike the way a few can be made, the more produced means more savings.
Consistency: This process guarantees that each part will be as nearly identical as possible while producing all parts to a very high quality and precision.
Flexibility in Design: Designers can put together difficult forms and features that are great for enclosures, brackets, and many other things.
Wasted Reduced: Since parts can be cut from a sheet of metal’s flat plane, less is wasted compared to other techniques.
What is CNC Machining?
CNC Machining is a subtractive manufacturing process in which machine tools controlled by computers remove material from a solid lump of metal, plastic or wood into a component.
All machines are programmed with particular requirements that determine the shape, size, and features of the final product.
Advantages of CNC Machining
High Accuracy: There can be very high precision in machining with CNC that allows making them perfect parts depending on tight tolerances.
Material Variety: It can work with a variety of materials, from metals to plastics and composite materials. It is, hence, quite flexible compared to stamping.
Complex Geometries: CNC can produce very detailed features like cavities, threads, and fine details, which are very hard to stamp.
Custom Prototyping: For rapid modification or adjustment to a custom part, prototyping by CNC machining is recommended because it is very convenient and fast without having to worry about issue tooling.
Lower Setup Costs at Low Volumes: Because a lot of upfront expenses were not needed for investment in tooling, CNC machining may pose lower costs at initial stages even on low production runs compared to stamping at these early stages.
Aluminum CNC milling machine part manufacturers can provide the best quality machining parts for your commercial applications.
Key Differences Between Sheet Metal Stamping and CNC Machining
1. Type of Process
Sheet metal stamping is part of the process of punching and stamping that is designed for manufacturing on a large scale. It will stamp the metal sheets into final shapes using dies.
CNC Machining is referred to as subtractive manufacturing because it subtracts material from a block until the final result is achieved. Any part can be constructed with CNC machining, however complex or detailed it might be.
2. Production Volume
Sheet Metal Stamping: Mostly applicable for production in large. That is because of its high efficiency and speed.
CNC Machining, as opposed to these two, is very adaptive for production in lesser quantities or custom work, which is what makes it the best option for prototyping or one-off designs.
3. Types of Applicable Materials
Sheet Metal Stamping: Works primarily with flat sheets of metals.
CNC Machining: Can accommodate most materials from different classes of metals to plastics and composite materials as well.
4. Cost
Although sheet Metal Stamping entails high initial costs because of die creation, the cost aspect is reduced quickly with a rise in volume of production per part.
CNC Machining: Costs less up front on small-run parts but can be more expensive than stamping in high quantities.
When to Select Sheet Metal Stamping
Choose sheet metal stamping if:
- There is a need for more than a large number of identical parts.
- The design can be done by using some flat sheets and simple forms.
- The economy requires high-volume production to gain lower unit costs per part.
When to Decide on CNC Machining
Choose CNC machining if:
- The components can be very complex and need to be built with very tight tolerances.
- The job will run the gamut from the kind of materials used to the different thicknesses.
Otherwise, it will require some flexibility in terms of prototyping or small-run production.
Conclusion
Both the techniques of sheet metal stamping and CNC machining have certain advantages to offer, unique to a certain specific production need. The method to choose must depend on the particular requirements of the project, such as volume, material, complexity, and budget.
If you require high quantity simple designs, then it is most likely that you would go with sheet metal stamping. Otherwise, your project requires high precision and a range of shapes; CNC machining may take the best.
Understanding both methods’ capabilities and limitations will go a long way in helping you find the most informed decision in line with your manufacturing objectives. The right choice can turn out to be a significant determinant for success with your project, either sheet metal stamping or CNC machining.
Aluminum precision custom CNC machining parts from JK Seiko offer the best quality products for businesses.
